Can white cloud minnows and oscars live together?
No. No shared temperature. White cloud minnow needs 60 to 72 F and Oscar needs 74 to 81 F. An adult oscar will eat white cloud minnows. Oscar is aggressive and will bully or kill white cloud minnows.
No, keep them apart
- Stocking
- Lightly stockedabout 53% of capacity
- Shared temperature
- Nonethese species cannot share a tank
- Shared pH
- 6.0 to 8.0smallest suitable tank: 75 gal
- Problem: No shared temperature. White cloud minnow needs 60 to 72 F and Oscar needs 74 to 81 F.
- Problem: An adult oscar will eat white cloud minnows.
- Problem: Oscar is aggressive and will bully or kill white cloud minnows.
Your tank
Fish are drawn at relative adult size, in the layer of the tank where they spend their time. Up to 12 of each are shown.
6 white cloud minnows1 oscar
Species in this tank
| Species | Count | Needs | Temperature | pH | Adult size |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| White cloud minnow | 6 | 10 gal, group of 6+ | 60 to 72 F | 6.0 to 8.0 | 1.5 in |
| Oscar | 1 | 75 gal, group of 1+ | 74 to 81 F | 6.0 to 8.0 | 12 in |
Pair by pair
| Pair | Together? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| White cloud minnow with Oscar | No | No shared temperature. White cloud minnow needs 60 to 72 F and Oscar needs 74 to 81 F. An adult oscar will eat white cloud minnows. Oscar is aggressive and will bully or kill white cloud minnows. |
Equipment and shopping plan
| Item | Get | Based on |
|---|---|---|
| Filter | at least 600 gallons per hour | 8 times the tank volume each hour |
| Heater | cannot be set for all species | about 4 watts per gallon in a normal room |
| Water change | 18.8 gallons a week | 25% weekly |
| Substrate | 94 lb of sand or fine gravel | about 1.25 lb per gallon |
| Test kit | ammonia, nitrite, nitrate and pH | Cycle the tank before adding fish |
Side by side
| White cloud minnow | Oscar | |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum tank | 10 gal | 75 gal |
| Temperature | 60 to 72 F | 74 to 81 F |
| pH | 6.0 to 8.0 | 6.0 to 8.0 |
| Temperament | Peaceful | Aggressive |
| Adult size | 1.5 in | 12 in |
| Group size | 6 or more | any |
Common questions
Can white cloud minnows and oscars live together?
No. No shared temperature. White cloud minnow needs 60 to 72 F and Oscar needs 74 to 81 F. An adult oscar will eat white cloud minnows. Oscar is aggressive and will bully or kill white cloud minnows.
What size tank do white cloud minnows and oscars need together?
75 gallons at minimum, the larger of what each species needs alone (10 for white cloud minnows, 75 for oscars). More room reduces squabbling and keeps the water steadier.
How many of each should I keep?
Keep at least 6 white cloud minnows. Oscars can be kept singly or in small numbers.