AquariumFitGuide

Can oscars and fancy goldfish live together?

No. Only a narrow shared temperature band, 74 to 75 F. One of them is always at the edge of its range. Oscar is aggressive and will bully or kill fancy goldfish. Goldfish are cool-water fish that produce a lot of waste. They are best kept with other goldfish.

No, keep them apart

What you want to keep
Stocking
Well stockedabout 65% of capacity
Shared temperature
74 to 75 Fset the heater to 75 F
Shared pH
7.0 to 8.0smallest suitable tank: 75 gal
  • Check: Only a narrow shared temperature band, 74 to 75 F. One of them is always at the edge of its range.
  • Problem: Oscar is aggressive and will bully or kill fancy goldfish.
  • Check: Goldfish are cool-water fish that produce a lot of waste. They are best kept with other goldfish.

Your tank

Fish are drawn at relative adult size, in the layer of the tank where they spend their time. Up to 12 of each are shown.

1 oscar1 fancy goldfish

Species in this tank

SpeciesCountNeedsTemperaturepHAdult size
Oscar175 gal, group of 1+74 to 81 F6.0 to 8.012 in
Fancy goldfish130 gal, group of 1+65 to 75 F7.0 to 8.08 in

Pair by pair

PairTogether?Why
Oscar with Fancy goldfishNoOnly a narrow shared temperature band, 74 to 75 F. One of them is always at the edge of its range. Oscar is aggressive and will bully or kill fancy goldfish. Goldfish are cool-water fish that produce a lot of waste. They are best kept with other goldfish.

Equipment and shopping plan

ItemGetBased on
Filterat least 600 gallons per hour8 times the tank volume each hour
Heater300 watts, set to 75 Fabout 4 watts per gallon in a normal room
Water change18.8 gallons a week25% weekly
Substrate94 lb of sand or fine gravelabout 1.25 lb per gallon
Test kitammonia, nitrite, nitrate and pHCycle the tank before adding fish

Side by side

OscarFancy goldfish
Minimum tank75 gal30 gal
Temperature74 to 81 F65 to 75 F
pH6.0 to 8.07.0 to 8.0
TemperamentAggressivePeaceful
Adult size12 in8 in
Group sizeanyany

Common questions

Can oscars and fancy goldfish live together?

No. Only a narrow shared temperature band, 74 to 75 F. One of them is always at the edge of its range. Oscar is aggressive and will bully or kill fancy goldfish. Goldfish are cool-water fish that produce a lot of waste. They are best kept with other goldfish.

What size tank do oscars and fancy goldfish need together?

75 gallons at minimum, the larger of what each species needs alone (75 for oscars, 30 for fancy goldfish). More room reduces squabbling and keeps the water steadier.

How many of each should I keep?

Oscars can be kept singly or in small numbers. Fancy goldfish can be kept singly or in small numbers.